One of my very favorite books of recent years was 2014’s Station Eleven, by Emily St. John Mandel. I loved that book so much that I couldn’t even bring myself to write a review of it; I just wanted to savor the memory of it, so to speak — to keep the memory unspoiled by words which would linger long afterwards, eventually becoming for me the memory themselves.
Three years after reading Station Eleven, I began encountering advance reviews of Peng Shepherd’s The Book of M, which often compared it — not at all unfavorably — with Station Eleven. Skeptical at first, I poked into the new book’s general nature, its premise and characters; in a way, though, I didn’t want to know too much in advance. Given such a premise and such characters, the anticipation of reading it resembled my memory of having read Station Eleven, in reverse: I didn’t want the words I read then to overhang the reading experience. So I quit reading advance reviews, placed a pre-release order, and just waited.
And all that intertwining of memory and language? It anticipated the very point.
—